designed with love made peacefully in NYC


With a love of great design, supporting important causes and fairness in the marketplace, Charmed By a Cause was created to bring these three things together. Our jewelry is designed for the altruistic who are mindful of what they buy and how and where it is crafted. “Made in NYC” means that we know the people we work with and that you can feel good about wearing our jewelry.

Equitable Pricing

Starting from a belief that fine jewelry should adorn rather than cost an arm and leg, we sell directly to you instead of department stores or boutiques. We design and manufacture locally so we can pass great savings on to you — fine jewelry minus the traditional retail markups — we believe in creating beautiful jewelry at a fair price. Our shop pages show 'Our Price' and the 'Suggested Traditional Retail' allowing our customers to see the difference in pricing when buying from our direct to consumer pricing model.

Yes, by not charging traditional retail pricing we still have room to give back. 20% of your purchase will support our cause partners and just as important wearing our pieces opens up a dialog and builds awareness for our cause partners. You'll choose your charity, and we'll donate 20% of the purchase price! Give yourself beautiful jewelry while you give back.

Quality Standards

Our jewelry is ethically made in NYC and designed and produced using sustainable materials. Our metals are 100% recycled 14kt gold and sterling silver, all natural stones are ethically-sourced and diamonds are lab grown or reclaimed. Plus, our production partner in NYC goes the extra mile to ensure all jewelry is crafted with the lightest carbon footprint possible.

Our Story From the Pages of Harper's Bazaar to Present

Founded by jewelry designers, Regan Caton and Betsy Milliken, the duo gained experience and notoriety in the industry with their successful line of costume jewelry, Rumblefish. Their pieces garnered praise from celebrities and top-notch magazines such as Vogue, WWD, Harper’s Bazaar, InStyle and more. The line was sold through Bergdorf Goodmans, Barneys, Saks Fifth Ave and various high-end boutiques.

 Fashion Magazine Covers

Regan Caton - Betsy MillikenAs time went on, life happened and Rumblefish was put on hold as Caton and Milliken’s paths took them in different directions. Thanks to their bond of friendship and shared passion for designing, the two launched Charmed By a Cause, a socially and environmentally responsible line of fine jewelry and charms.

Charmed By a Cause is an inspiring brand that is operated in both New York City and Montclair, New Jersey, just 12 miles west of Manhattan. Driven by their mission to give back and form meaningful connections, Charmed By a Cause offers timeless pieces, plus the opportunity to create custom charms that will help raise awareness and funds for non-profits and organizations, jewelry that inspires and speaks for itself.